Burr Alert: Evolving Bankruptcy Jurisdiction - Ninth Circuit Rules that Bankruptcy Courts Cannot Enter Final Judgment on Fraudulent Conveyance Claims

January 24, 2013

Before the Supreme Court’s seminal ruling in Stern v. Marshall,1 bankruptcy courts regularly entered final orders in fraudulent conveyance actions and other "core"2 matters. In Stern v. Marshall, the Supreme Court ruled that despite being statutorily defined as "core" under the bankruptcy code, bankruptcy courts do not have the constitutional power to adjudicate counterclaims to proofs of claim because they are based in state law. Following the same course, the Ninth Circuit recently held in In re Bellingham Insurance Agency, Inc.,3 that a non-Article III bankruptcy judge lacks constitutional authority to enter a final judgment on a fraudulent conveyance action against a nonclaimant to a bankruptcy estate.

To read more about this topic, please see full article below:

Download PDF


Legal Disclaimer:
No representation is made that the quality of services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.

Featured Attorneys

send article

TESTIMONIALS

  • "I am an employee of a large bank and responsible for a complex commercial real estate portfolio of problem loans and special assets.  I find Erich to be a most valuable resource and team member.  Erich is totally engaged in evaluating the bank's position related to the debt obligation(s), the collateral securing the debt and, when possible, offering alternative solutions that oftentimes lead to enhanced resolutions benefiting both the customer and the bank.  His proactive problem identification, problem prevention and problem solving skills make him my "go to" legal counsel."

    -Anonymous

  • "Gail is extremely efficient and responsive which makes our closing process go smoothly and allows us to meet tight closing deadlines.  A reputation for having a seamless and timely closing process helps give us an edge over the competition to obtain the deal.  Gail is an excellent communicator and develops a high level of trust and respect with our team as well as with our clients."

    -Sarah S. Duggan, Seniors Housing and Healthcare Lending, Synovus Financial Corporation

  • β€œA very good lawyer.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • "Very good."

    -Chambers 2012

  • β€œHe is great. He is not only bright, but has a good way of getting things done. Any time we have had a transaction and there was a disagreement, he is the best to work through. He has the magic touch, never gets mad, always gets the deal done.”

    -Chambers 2012