Burr Alert: Evolving Bankruptcy Jurisdiction - Ninth Circuit Rules that Bankruptcy Courts Cannot Enter Final Judgment on Fraudulent Conveyance Claims

January 24, 2013

Before the Supreme Court’s seminal ruling in Stern v. Marshall,1 bankruptcy courts regularly entered final orders in fraudulent conveyance actions and other "core"2 matters. In Stern v. Marshall, the Supreme Court ruled that despite being statutorily defined as "core" under the bankruptcy code, bankruptcy courts do not have the constitutional power to adjudicate counterclaims to proofs of claim because they are based in state law. Following the same course, the Ninth Circuit recently held in In re Bellingham Insurance Agency, Inc.,3 that a non-Article III bankruptcy judge lacks constitutional authority to enter a final judgment on a fraudulent conveyance action against a nonclaimant to a bankruptcy estate.

To read more about this topic, please see full article below:

Download PDF


Legal Disclaimer:
No representation is made that the quality of services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.

Featured Attorneys

send article

TESTIMONIALS

  • “Does have a fairly significant commercial real estate group.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • “She is very competent in advising us on the deal – many of us didn’t realize the significance or the terminology. She is very thorough and is very good at explaining how the deals worked and what it was.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • “He is efficient and understands me. He knows the balance between legal and business aspects.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • “Very much a documentation person. She is behind the scenes and explains things very well. She...has wonderful skills.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • "I appreciate Erich's attention to detail.  He is always responsive to my requests, particularly when the matter is time sensitive.  I have found that his advice on course of action is always sound.  I always feel that Erich has the best interests of the Bank in mind when recommending strategy."

    -Anonymous