Burr Alert: Evolving Bankruptcy Jurisdiction - Ninth Circuit Rules that Bankruptcy Courts Cannot Enter Final Judgment on Fraudulent Conveyance Claims

January 24, 2013

Before the Supreme Court’s seminal ruling in Stern v. Marshall,1 bankruptcy courts regularly entered final orders in fraudulent conveyance actions and other "core"2 matters. In Stern v. Marshall, the Supreme Court ruled that despite being statutorily defined as "core" under the bankruptcy code, bankruptcy courts do not have the constitutional power to adjudicate counterclaims to proofs of claim because they are based in state law. Following the same course, the Ninth Circuit recently held in In re Bellingham Insurance Agency, Inc.,3 that a non-Article III bankruptcy judge lacks constitutional authority to enter a final judgment on a fraudulent conveyance action against a nonclaimant to a bankruptcy estate.

To read more about this topic, please see full article below:

Download PDF


Legal Disclaimer:
No representation is made that the quality of services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.

Featured Attorneys

send article

TESTIMONIALS

  • “I have found them very responsive to our requests and requirements, and very knowledgeable of the relevant areas. They are conscious of cost containment and getting the job done. They don’t just churn paper and create billable hours. Everything they do is directed toward achieving our aims. They want us as the client to understand where things are and what our options are, and make sure we understand the consequences of all the options that are available to us. They let us pick door number one or door number two in the knowledge of what we’re leaving behind. They are able to resolve issues using common sense and reasonableness. We speak very highly of them.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • “Melinda Sellers has provided a high level of service to our company. She provides thorough research, high level of organization to any matter, and persuasive legal writing. She has a bright legal career ahead of her.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • “I have had the pleasure of working with Jay Price since 1997.  Over the years, he has provided outstanding representation for the banks I have worked for and continues to make the loan closing process a good experience for both the bank and our borrowers.  Even with the growth of Jay’s practice over the years, he always makes me feel as if I am his only client and always provides me top notch service.”

    -Anonymous

  • "Heather is a great lawyer; however, one of her best attributes is that she also thinks like a business person. She understands our needs and gives us practical, real-world advice -- not something you get from many lawyers."

    -Jeffrey M. Pomeroy, Bayer Properties

  • “Gail is a trusted advisor who provides great insight to solving problems and getting deals to the finish line.  She is always quick to respond to our needs and I believe there is great value in the counsel she provides.”

    -Chris Brown, Vulcan Real Estate Partners, LLC