Burr Alert: Preemption of State Consumer Protection Laws Under the Dodd-Frank Act

February 19, 2013

 

The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (“Dodd-Frank Act” or the “Act”), signed into law in 2010, contains a series of regulatory reforms aimed in part to combat what was perceived as lax financial regulation that led to the recession of the late 2000’s.1 One way the Dodd-Frank Act seeks to tighten the reins on national banking institutions is by strengthening the legal standards for the preemption of state laws, thereby making it harder for banks to avoid liability under state law. Whereas prior to Dodd-Frank’s enactment, national banking institutions enjoyed heavy deference in the area of preemption of state laws, Dodd-Frank curbs this deference by requiring a case by case determination of preemption and requiring that a state consumer financial services law conflict with the exercise of a national bank’s powers before the state law can be preempted. Further, the Dodd-Frank Act strips subsidiaries of national banks of the same preemption protection enjoyed by national banks and subjects federally-chartered savings banks and federally-regulated savings associations to the same preemption standards as those applicable to national banks. The mandated “case by case” determination standard injects much uncertainty into the preemption analysis and ensures much preemption litigation for years to come.

Download full alert




Legal Disclaimer:
No representation is made that the quality of services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.

Featured Attorneys

send article

TESTIMONIALS

  • “A great lawyer, deserving of the ranking.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • “He is great. The most important thing I think is judgment, whether more aggressive or more conservative than a firm’s first inclination. Tom’s got a great sense of discretion and judgment and he clearly knows the topic area very well. We never have an issue with us having to prompt ‘try this theory’. He’s smart and very pleasant, responsive as anything.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • "Burr & Forman has excellent skills with a strong understanding of the business situation."

    -Best Lawyers 2012

  • “I have worked with Chris Linde and Eric Golden on two separate legal matters.  In both, their level headedness and systematic approach to the various outcomes were planned and continually communicated with me. I felt very much a part of the process. While the legal process was drawn out due to the court system, Chris and Eric made the process as smooth as possible and never promised anything they knew they couldn't deliver on.  I highly recommend both of them for legal issues and will definitely retain them again on new issues that may arise.”

    -John Lehr, MD

  • “Probably the smartest human being to whom I can honestly refer to as a friend. His practice covers securities, banks, investment banking transactions, anything remotely financially related, personal financial investments as well. He is just smart as hell and has a mastery of a fairly wide array of disciplines which is a little unusual. He has the mental capacity to go beyond that. He is also one of the first guys I call.”

    -Chambers 2012