Burr Alert: Preemption of State Consumer Protection Laws Under the Dodd-Frank Act

February 19, 2013

 

The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (“Dodd-Frank Act” or the “Act”), signed into law in 2010, contains a series of regulatory reforms aimed in part to combat what was perceived as lax financial regulation that led to the recession of the late 2000’s.1 One way the Dodd-Frank Act seeks to tighten the reins on national banking institutions is by strengthening the legal standards for the preemption of state laws, thereby making it harder for banks to avoid liability under state law. Whereas prior to Dodd-Frank’s enactment, national banking institutions enjoyed heavy deference in the area of preemption of state laws, Dodd-Frank curbs this deference by requiring a case by case determination of preemption and requiring that a state consumer financial services law conflict with the exercise of a national bank’s powers before the state law can be preempted. Further, the Dodd-Frank Act strips subsidiaries of national banks of the same preemption protection enjoyed by national banks and subjects federally-chartered savings banks and federally-regulated savings associations to the same preemption standards as those applicable to national banks. The mandated “case by case” determination standard injects much uncertainty into the preemption analysis and ensures much preemption litigation for years to come.

Download full alert




Legal Disclaimer:
No representation is made that the quality of services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.

Featured Attorneys

send article

TESTIMONIALS

  • “The coordination between each individual attorney appeared smooth. I was happy with the client service.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • “It is my pleasure to recommend Howard and the healthcare team at Burr & Forman.  From issues related to medical staff bylaws, through numerous regulatory compliance and certificate-of-need applications, to the successful resolution of the largest Medicare recoupment effort against a private medical practice; Howard has always been a knowledgeable counselor, keen advisor and staunch advocate for the hospitals and medical practices I have managed. 

    Howard’s record of accomplishment is broad and impressive.  He is quick to respond when called.  His advocacy style is reassuring as he blends superior organizational skills, subject matter expertise and a willingness to listen and grasp the full understanding of his client’s needs and objectives.  

    This recommendation is made without reservation because for nineteen years, when my own reputation was at stake, I have introduced Howard to the organizations I manage.  In every case, the organization has benefitted greatly as he has managed to achieve the best outcomes possible.”

    -G. Thomas Brown, CEO, Eye Specialty Group and Ridge Lake Ambulatory Surgery Center

  • "Rik is a character, a trial lawyer of the highest degree. He is a consummate trial attorney and a phenomenal oral advocate with an ability to take complex issues and make sense of them, build out and present them in a common sense way.”

    -Chambers 2012

  • “Michael did work for us while I was CEO at Guided Therapeutics and after spending literally millions on patent work, I have to say that Michael is one of the best IP attorneys that I have ever worked with. I highly recommend him. Almost any attorney can get a patent issued, however the real trick is to get a patent issued that has real value and can stand against litigation. Michael is also especially knowledgeable in foreign IP rights and is very cost effective.”

    -Mark Samuels, CEO, Guided Therapeutics, medical device manufacturer

  • “We frequently call on Kristin to provide us with guidance on various employee situations, from hiring to firing and all that goes in between.  Not only is Kristin extremely knowledgeable in the employment law arena, but we appreciate the fact that Kristin does not take a “one size fits all” approach with her clients.  Instead, she took the time to learn and know our company, so that her legal advice is always rendered after having been tailored for the specific needs of and in consideration of the character that is Southeast Roofing’s alone.” 

    -Southeast Roofing and Construction, Inc.