Does the No Surprises Act Apply to Self-Pay Patients and Nonparticipating Practices?

Article

Many cash-only practices that do not participate with commercial insurers, or that collect payment directly from patients, assume the No Surprises Act (NSA) does not reach them because it is a law about insurance. However, the NSA contains two distinct sets of requirements, and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has taken the position that network status matters for only one of them.

This article walks through what a cash pay, nonparticipating provider must do in its own office, and then turns to the situation that creates the most risk: the cash pay surgeon who operates at an ambulatory surgical center (ASC) or hospital that participates in the health plan of the patient.

Two Sets of Rules

The first set of rules is the balance billing protections. They belong to patients who are enrolled in a group health plan or in group or individual health insurance, and they apply only to services the plan covers. They limit what a nonparticipating provider may collect from the patient for emergency services, for nonemergency services furnished at a participating hospital, hospital outpatient department, critical access hospital, or ASC, and for air ambulance services.

The second set is the good faith estimate (GFE) requirement. It protects patients who are uninsured or self-pay, and CMS takes the position it applies to every licensed or certified provider and facility without regard to network status.

Neither set generally applies to patients enrolled in Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, or another federal healthcare program. A physician who has opted out of Medicare must follow the Medicare private contract rules for those patients instead.  Providers should review their state’s Medicaid program rules to determine the appropriate process.

The Cash Practice in Its Own Office

A nonparticipating physician who sees patients only in his or her own office is generally outside the balance billing protections, because an office is not one of the listed facilities. The practice may bill according to its financial agreement with the patient. CMS has taken the position that the GFE requirement, however, applies in full, even if the practice obtains a signed fee agreement. A cash practice should build the following steps into its scheduling and billing process.

  • Ask every patient about coverage: At scheduling, ask whether the patient has health coverage and, if so, whether the patient intends to submit a claim for the service. A patient with no coverage is uninsured. A patient with coverage who does not intend to submit a claim is self-pay. Patients covered only by a short-term plan or a healthcare sharing ministry are generally treated as uninsured.
  • Understand who is not self-pay: A patient who pays the practice directly but plans to file a claim for out of network reimbursement is not self-pay under the rule. A GFE is not currently required for that patient, although many practices provide one as a matter of good practice.
  • Post and give notice: Post notice of the right to receive a GFE in the office, on the practice website, and wherever scheduling or questions about cost occur. Also tell uninsured and self-pay patients orally when they schedule or ask about cost. CMS publishes a model notice.
  • Meet the deadlines: When a service is scheduled at least three business days in advance, deliver the GFE within one business day after scheduling. When a service is scheduled at least ten business days in advance, or when a patient requests an estimate, deliver it within three business days. CMS treats any discussion of cost as a request. A GFE is not required for emergencies, for walk in visits, or for services scheduled fewer than three business days in advance.
  • Include the required content: The GFE must identify the patient and describe the primary service. It must itemize the items and services reasonably expected to be furnished with that service, with diagnosis codes, service codes, and the expected charge for each. It must also give the name, National Provider Identifier, and Tax Identification Number of the provider and the location where services will be furnished. The expected charge is the cash price the practice actually expects to bill, after any discount.
  • Include the required disclaimers: The GFE must state that it is only an estimate that actual charges may differ, that it is not a contract, and that the patient may initiate a dispute if billed charges substantially exceed the estimate.
  • Deliver it in writing: Provide the GFE on paper or electronically, as the patient prefers. An oral estimate does not satisfy the rule.
  • Keep it current: Issue a new GFE if the expected scope or charges change before the service. A single GFE may cover recurring services for up to 12 months.
  • Retain it: The GFE is part of the medical record and must be kept for six years.

When other providers or facilities will bill separately for the same episode of care, the provider that schedules the primary service is the convening provider and is ultimately expected to collect and include their charges. HHS continues to exercise enforcement discretion for a GFE that omits those charges, but each provider remains responsible for an accurate estimate of its own.

When the Bill Exceeds the Estimate

If the billed charges of a provider exceed the GFE from that provider by $400 or more, the patient may initiate the patient provider dispute resolution process within 120 calendar days of receiving the bill. An independent dispute resolution entity reviews the GFE, the bill, and any documentation from the provider showing that the additional charges reflect medically necessary items or services arising from circumstances that could not reasonably have been anticipated. The reviewer then decides whether the patient owes the estimated amount, the billed amount, or something in between.

While a dispute is pending, the provider may not send the bill to collections, threaten to do so, or charge late fees on the unpaid amount. The practical lesson is to estimate carefully, to document the reason for any change in scope, and to issue an updated GFE before the service whenever possible.

The Cash Pay Surgeon at a Participating ASC

CMS’ analysis changes when a nonparticipating provider leaves the office. Consider a surgeon who accepts no insurance and charges a fixed cash price, but who operates at an ASC that is in network with many commercial plans. CMS’ position is that the obligations of the surgeon depend on the coverage of the patient.

If the patient is uninsured, only the GFE requirement applies. The surgeon is typically the convening provider, and the ASC and any other providers are expected to furnish their own estimates.

If the patient is enrolled in a commercial plan, the ASC participates in that plan, and the procedure is a covered benefit, CMS takes the position that the balance billing protections apply to the surgeon by default. That is true even though the surgeon has no contract with the plan and has never billed it. Without more, the surgeon may collect from the patient only the in-network cost sharing amount and must look to the plan for the balance, through the open negotiation and independent dispute resolution process if necessary. A cash price agreement signed by the patient does not change that result.

The NSA does offer a path for this surgeon. Because surgery is not an ancillary service, the surgeon may use the notice and consent exception, under which the patient knowingly waives the protections. The requirements are strict:

  • The surgeon, or the ASC acting on behalf of the surgeon, must use the standard HHS notice and consent form. A form drafted by the practice is not sufficient.
  • The form must be given separately from other documents and must include a good faith estimate of the charges of the surgeon.
  • When the procedure is scheduled at least 72 hours in advance, the form must be given at least 72 hours before the procedure. When it is scheduled closer in time, the form must be given on the day the appointment is made and no later than three hours before the procedure. Consent may not be sought at the time of care.
  • The patient must sign the form. Consent may not be given orally or by telephone.
  • The patient must receive a signed copy in person, by mail, or by email, as the patient prefers.
  • The signed form must be kept for seven years by the surgeon or by the ASC.
  • Consent must be voluntary. An incomplete form is treated as no consent at all.
  • When consent is obtained, the surgeon should notify the plan that the patient has waived the protections.

Three limits on the exception deserve attention:

  • The exception is never available for ancillary services. These include anesthesiology, pathology, radiology, laboratory and other diagnostic services, and the services of an assistant surgeon. If the cash pay surgeon brings a nonparticipating anesthesiologist or assistant surgeon to the ASC, those providers may collect only in network cost sharing from an insured patient, no matter what the patient signs.
  • The exception is not available when no participating provider at the ASC could furnish the procedure. If the surgeon is the only one at the facility who performs it, the patient cannot be asked to consent.
  • The exception does not cover items or services that result from unforeseen, urgent medical needs that arise during the procedure.

Cash pay surgeons often ask whether the insured patient may simply agree not to use insurance. An insured patient who does not intend to submit a claim is treated as self-pay for purposes of the GFE requirement. CMS guidance does not clearly say that the same election removes the balance billing protections, which are written in terms of whether the patient is enrolled in a plan and receives a covered service at a participating facility. The position is especially difficult to defend when the ASC bills the plan for its facility fee for the same procedure. The prudent course is to use the notice and consent process whenever an insured patient will receive a covered procedure at a participating ASC, and not to rely on a private cash agreement alone.

The protections do not apply to a procedure the plan does not cover, such as a purely cosmetic procedure. In that case the patient is responsible for the charges and the GFE requirement governs.

Finally, a provider who furnishes services at a facility must make a disclosure of the balance billing protections available to insured patients. The surgeon should confirm, preferably in writing, whether the ASC will provide that disclosure on behalf of the surgeon, which party will deliver and retain the notice and consent form, and how the two will exchange estimates.

State Law and Penalties

State balance billing and price transparency laws may impose additional or stricter requirements, and some state laws displace the federal rules for plans regulated by the state. Violations of the federal requirements can result in civil money penalties of up to $10,000 per violation.

Takeaways

CMS has increased enforcement activity and its position is that a cash practice that never signs a payer contract and never leaves its own office is still subject to the GFE requirement for every uninsured and self-pay patient. CMS further mandates that a cash pay provider who furnishes services at a participating hospital or ASC is subject to both sets of rules, and for insured patients the cash price is collectible only with a valid notice and consent. Practices in either category should confirm that their intake questions, posted notices, estimate templates, and consent procedures are in place before the next patient is scheduled.

Related Professionals

Burr
Jump to Page
Arrow icon Top

Contact Us

Cookie Preference Center

Necessary Cookies

Always Active

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. These cookies may only be disabled by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Analytical Cookies

Analytical cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.